Reading on the screen

Just about every English teacher I know is passionate about books and reading. Loves it. Is good at it.
They (we) love books. The smell, the feel, the texture, the excitement of a new book. And, if I had $1 for every one I’d heard say something like “I couldn’t possibly read a book on the screen”, then I could buy an ipad.
So, it was funny the other day teaching Jane Austen to my Lit class and talking about some important passages that were revealing about Austen’s views and values to look up and see one of the girls looking at her computer, not the dog-eared Penguin Classic everyone else had open.
When I asked her why she wasn’t looking at the passage we were discussing,she said she was, but that she preferred to read it on the screen, where she could annotate it direct and make notes on the discussion somewhere else than in the margin. It wasn’t so much as an ‘aha’ moment, as a ‘oh yeah’ moment. I did give them the text version of Emma from Project Gutenberg and had encouraged them to use it to find quotes or to pull apart key passages. But, I hadn’t thought that some students actually PREFER to read this way. That it’s not all about the book for everyone any more (if it ever was)
And I find myself reading more and more on the screen now. Not just online newspapers and the reports from the Giro cycling race in Italy. But substantive articles, even books. I read The Call of the Wild for the first time ever on the plane going to the USA, on my ipod application called Classics, which had 24 other classics I could have chosen. Or, from another app called Classics2Go which has 60 classics from Wuthering Heights to The Adventures of Huckleberry Finn. Or, I could have opened up Grimm’s fairy tales or the Shakespeare app I paid a couple of dollars for which contains ALL of Shakespeare’s plays and poetry. A lot more choice than I could fit in my take-on luggage.
So, if my reading behaviour is changing, little wonder that our students are going to have less qualms and want more opportunities to be doing their reading in a new format. The stories remain the same.
Below and above: screen shots from my ipod-touch and the apps I’ve talked about above.

Cross-posted at English Teaching it IT (with more screenshots)

4 thoughts on “Reading on the screen

  1. I recently purchased a Kindle. It more than useful for books but when I mastered .txt the whole world opened up with articles to transfer to it.

    I am with you on the cycling but live coverage on Eurosports each night is better.

    cheers Martin

  2. Do you think we will ever get to the stage where all reading will be done on the screen? I hope not. There is nothing like curling up with a good book … it just wouldn’t be the same with an ipad (despite the fact that the ipad is very cool!)

  3. I can’t really see it for all reading Anna, probably ever. Books are a pretty cool little bit of technology aren’t they. I plan to get an ipad later in the year and will have a go at reading some books that way, and might even experiment a bit with audio books, which some people rave about.

    Stay warm!

  4. eBooks will never replace paper books, in the same way that cinema never replaced theatre, or television replaced cinema.

    New technologies rarely replace older technologies, usually they add to the experience.

    eBooks and other online resources give learners choice, and this means we can provide a more diverse learning experience to meeting the differing needs of learners much more easily.


Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s